Rubgy brain injury lawsuits face collapse after six-year legal battle

By Published On: 20 November 2026
Rubgy brain injury lawsuits face collapse after six-year legal battle

Two separate rugby brain injury lawsuits involving hundreds of players face collapse after claimants missed another deadline to disclose medical records.

The cases have been in legal proceedings for six years. Their future now depends on whether two judges grant the claimants another extension to provide outstanding medical documents.

Lawyers representing World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union and the Welsh Rugby Union argue that the claimants have repeatedly failed to comply with court orders requiring them to disclose medical documents.

The latest hearings were intended to move the cases towards a trial scheduled to begin in October 2027, with both sides due to submit shortlists of potential test cases.

But the defendants say they cannot complete that process because they have still not received the necessary medical records.

Instead, the hearings have focused on whether the two lawsuits should now be treated as struck out following further breaches of court orders.

The claimants have previously been granted relief from that sanction. Their lawyers are now seeking another extension until January.

The decision rests with Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter.

Paul Downes KC, lead counsel for the players, acknowledged in June that the claimants were in the “last-chance saloon” after repeatedly missing disclosure deadlines.

Further deadlines were missed in October, raising questions about whether the proceedings can continue.

KP Law, which took over representing the players in June, inherited the cases from Rylands Garth, a law firm that is no longer involved in the litigation.

Downes described the state of the proceedings when KP Law took over as “shambolic” and called the previous firm’s work an “incredible failure”.

KP Law has since supplied another 2,000 documents relating to medical testing.

The firm argues that “more has been achieved in the last 99 days than in the previous three years”.

Despite that progress, substantial gaps remain in the medical evidence.

In the rugby union case, one of the two lawsuits, the court heard that only 36 of the 385 players had letters confirming their diagnoses.

Mr Justice Cotter questioned how claimants had been accepted into the litigation without that documentation.

“It seems remarkable that anyone has been onboarded without a letter of diagnosis,” he said.

Downes also told the court that Rylands Garth had not maintained a single database showing which documents had been provided and which were still outstanding.

He said the former firm had refused to share its existing files with KP Law until “some sort of exit agreement” was reached.

The continuing problems with medical records have left both lawsuits facing a potentially decisive ruling.

Downes maintained that the proceedings could still be brought back on track despite the missed deadlines.

“If it can be saved, it is my submission that it should be saved.”

CTE found in less that 1% of brain donors with no contact sport history
Post